I think Storm is being flippant but I don’t think she is an asshole or should shut the fuck up.
Storm has absolutely faced discrimination as a result of her powers. She is still a mutant. She is still hunted by the government who want to lock her away in a cage.
Now, I don’t in any way want to discount the pain that Rogue has had to endure. She faces the same problems Storm faces, PLUS the curse of her power causing her to be touch starved and the inadvertent pain she has caused others.
It’s understandable why offering such a cure would be appealing for Rogue. But let’s not forget Rogue has slowly gained more control over her powers. She can have physical contact with people, she even gets to enjoy their powers for a brief time.
Forcing the “cure” on people is the problem. Forcing them through fear or forcing them as a means of control. That’s the problem. It’s totally fine if Rogue decides to take the cure and is of sound body and mind.
Just because a sizable population sees Rogue as a “freak” doesn’t mean that she is one. Storm is reminding her that there is nothing wrong with her. She doesn’t have to make this choice. She’s reminding Rogue that she has friends, she has a (found) family, she has support.
Should Storm perhaps be a little more tactful in how she approaches it? Sure. But she is absolutely right to say it.
rogue literally kills people she touches, it remains baffling that people go “oh but she learned to control her powers”, would you like to try living with the knowledge that if you lose control while petting your cat it fucking dies?
i’ve literally had nightmares about crushing a hamster while trying to hold it in my hands, if xmen was real it would be an astounding feat of mental fortitude for rogue to have not offed herself out of sheer existential dread.
That’s not what I meant, and it isn’t entirely accurate anyway. Her power absorbs the energy of the people she touches, it doesn’t just kill them.
I don’t believe Rogue has ever killed anyone with her touch by accident. The most obvious counterpoint would be Carol Danvers, but that situation had as much to do with Ms. Marvel’s powers as it did Rogue’s. Maybe you’re confusing her with another character that has an instant death poke, but in most universes, Rogue’s powers aren’t inherently more dangerous than the average mutant’s, providing she accepts them as part of herself.
She was traumatized by nearly killing someone when her X-Gene first activated, and she refused to gain any sort of mastery over her powers for a long time because of that. Just like other mutants, Rogue’s abilities are core to her identity, and a huge part of her journey was acknowledging that fact and learning to control them. If she had followed your sentiments, she probably wouldn’t have made that journey.
I think Storm is being flippant but I don’t think she is an asshole or should shut the fuck up.
Storm has absolutely faced discrimination as a result of her powers. She is still a mutant. She is still hunted by the government who want to lock her away in a cage.
Now, I don’t in any way want to discount the pain that Rogue has had to endure. She faces the same problems Storm faces, PLUS the curse of her power causing her to be touch starved and the inadvertent pain she has caused others.
It’s understandable why offering such a cure would be appealing for Rogue. But let’s not forget Rogue has slowly gained more control over her powers. She can have physical contact with people, she even gets to enjoy their powers for a brief time.
Forcing the “cure” on people is the problem. Forcing them through fear or forcing them as a means of control. That’s the problem. It’s totally fine if Rogue decides to take the cure and is of sound body and mind.
Just because a sizable population sees Rogue as a “freak” doesn’t mean that she is one. Storm is reminding her that there is nothing wrong with her. She doesn’t have to make this choice. She’s reminding Rogue that she has friends, she has a (found) family, she has support.
Should Storm perhaps be a little more tactful in how she approaches it? Sure. But she is absolutely right to say it.
rogue literally kills people she touches, it remains baffling that people go “oh but she learned to control her powers”, would you like to try living with the knowledge that if you lose control while petting your cat it fucking dies?
i’ve literally had nightmares about crushing a hamster while trying to hold it in my hands, if xmen was real it would be an astounding feat of mental fortitude for rogue to have not offed herself out of sheer existential dread.
But she doesn’t kill the people she touches, usually
my brother in christ of nazareth, listen to yourself
“she only kills them sometimes!”
That’s not what I meant, and it isn’t entirely accurate anyway. Her power absorbs the energy of the people she touches, it doesn’t just kill them.
I don’t believe Rogue has ever killed anyone with her touch by accident. The most obvious counterpoint would be Carol Danvers, but that situation had as much to do with Ms. Marvel’s powers as it did Rogue’s. Maybe you’re confusing her with another character that has an instant death poke, but in most universes, Rogue’s powers aren’t inherently more dangerous than the average mutant’s, providing she accepts them as part of herself.
She was traumatized by nearly killing someone when her X-Gene first activated, and she refused to gain any sort of mastery over her powers for a long time because of that. Just like other mutants, Rogue’s abilities are core to her identity, and a huge part of her journey was acknowledging that fact and learning to control them. If she had followed your sentiments, she probably wouldn’t have made that journey.