With Lidarr being not very functional due to the Unable to communicate with LidarrAPI - Lidarr API “Internal Server Error” 500 | Invalid response received from LidarrAPI | HTTP Request Timeout · Issue #5498 · Lidarr/Lidarr I have been thinking about getting rid of it altogether. I have only started using it recently and don’t like it.

What I use Lidarr for:

  • Find metadata for music
    • organize files in a consistent way base on metadata
    • obtain album art
    • create .nfo or other files
  • Identify desired music and instruct download utility to get it (this is optional for me— I can handle myself if needed)
  • Do the above via a web interface which can be browsed nicely

I don’t like about Lidarr:

  • The not-really-open-source nature of it, e.g. this current problem, where you are reliant on their external server to run your own home server. I feel this might be a more pervasive issue in the Arrs but not sure of all the implications
  • How unsupported it is to include work that the lidarr servers don’t know about. There will never be a metadata database which includes all music. There is just too much music in the world!
  • no audiobook/podcast support

I also have Jellyfin going for the actual serving/streaming of the music. Am not sure if it is able to fully manage the metadata and files?

Lots of options in the awesome-selfhosted list.

I could use a linux desktop app if it was better than a selfhosted server.

Thoughts?

  • layzerjeyt@lemmy.dbzer0.comOP
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    16 hours ago

    I tried beets but it takes so long to do any task. Even if I just ask it to look up 1 album. beet import /path/to/album I got frustrated trying to learn it.

    Was surprised about being unable to find any --verbose argument so I could at least see what was going on. Does it just take forever to do anything?

    • NebulaNymph@programming.dev
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      8 hours ago

      I’d recommend going through the documentation for beets, they have great guides on using the auto tagger and importing music!

      (If it is ‘taking forever’ to look up 1 album there is likely an issue with your config or beets install, following the docs can help with this!)

      Beets Docs